Is Arcadia Bluffs Worth the Money?

Yes, for the right group, Arcadia Bluffs is worth the money. I plan Michigan golf trips for a living, and it's the course I get asked about more than any other. It's also the most expensive public round most Michigan groups will ever book, so the question deserves a real answer instead of a brochure. Here's the honest math, who the trip fits, and the handful of decisions that separate a group that got its money's worth from a group that paid the same and didn't.

What it costs, in plain terms

There are three courses on the property, and they're priced like three different trips. The Bluffs Course, the one on the magazine covers, runs $285 a round at summer peak, with cart and range included. The South Course, a true links design that serious golfers sometimes prefer, plays for roughly a third less. The Dozen, their 12 hole par 3 short course along the water, costs about what a good dinner does and is the sneaky best add-on in Northern Michigan. The fall rate drops it closer to $175 in early October, which is one of the levers I use for value-minded groups.

So a two round weekend built around the Bluffs, with a relaxed second course nearby, lands most groups in the $400 to $500 range per golfer on greens fees, before lodging and meals. Lodging swings the total more than golf does. On-property rooms and cottages cost resort money and buy you a zero-commute morning; basing in Frankfort, the harbor town about 25 minutes north, costs less and gives the trip a real downtown at night. The full trip budget picture, with every cost category, lives on the what a Michigan golf trip costs page.

When it's worth it

The Bluffs earns its fee when three things are true. The group has at least one bucket-list round in its budget and wants it to feel like an event. Everyone can handle wind and elevated green fees without the round turning into a grind about money. And the trip is built around the course, not squeezed around it. Arcadia sits alone on Lake Michigan an hour from the nearest golf cluster, so it rewards groups who commit to it as the centerpiece.

It's the wrong buy when the group runs on value golf. If the trip you love is 36 holes a day at $70 courses, the Sunrise Side and the West Branch corridor will make you happier than one $300 round ever will. It's also the wrong first splurge for a group with beginners; the exposure and the wind are real, and there's no tree line to hide a swing behind.

How I'd make the money count

Play the Bluffs first, fresh, on day one, with the whole group together. It's the round the weekend is built around, so it should never be the one somebody misses to a late flight or dead legs.

Take a morning tee time. The course is fully exposed on the bluffs above Lake Michigan, and the afternoon wind turns it into a different and meaner course. A morning round and an afternoon round on the Bluffs are two different purchases at the same price. Warm up on the range first, and pack a layer and a shell even in July.

Don't buy a second marquee round. The mistake I see most is groups trying to match the Bluffs on day two. The right second round is the relaxed one. Wolf River Golf Park, fifteen minutes away in Bear Lake, is wide, forgiving, one of the best sub-$100 values in the state, and the contrast is what makes the weekend feel complete. If the budget has room for one more swing at the property, The Dozen at sunset does more for a group's memory of the trip than a second $300 round does.

Where to base

Stay on property if the golf is the whole point. You wake up steps from the first tee, breakfast is handled, and the morning that matters has no drive in it. The four bedroom Cottages are the natural call for a foursome, and it's worth asking about stay-and-play rates when you book.

Base in Frankfort if the evenings matter as much as the rounds. Stormcloud Brewing on Main Street is the natural group night, Birch and Maple is the dress-up dinner, Port City Smokehouse is the easy night. The Arcadia Scenic Turnout on M-22 is five minutes from the course and one of the best Lake Michigan overlooks anywhere, and Sleeping Bear Dunes is 45 minutes north if the group wants a non-golf half day.

The booking clock decides more than the budget does

Bluffs tee times for the coming season open in November, and that window is the real deadline for this trip. Miss it and you're negotiating with what's left, usually afternoon times, which on this course means buying the windy version. Lodging runs on its own earlier clock. The move is to lock dates, hold lodging, then take the Bluffs time the moment the window opens. The full two-clock timing is on the best time for Northern Michigan golf page. Flying in, Cherry Capital in Traverse City is about 90 minutes out, which is why plenty of groups fold Arcadia into a bigger Traverse City trip.

The bottom line

Worth it, if you buy it right. The groups that regret Arcadia paid peak money for an afternoon tee time, chased a second trophy round, and slept in the wrong place for how their group travels. The groups that rave about it played the Bluffs fresh on a calm morning, relaxed at Wolf River, and let the property or Frankfort do what each does best. Same course, same money, completely different trip.

Not sure you need help pulling it together? That question is answered on the do you need a Michigan golf trip planner page.

See Also